Heart & Science International compass badge HEART & SCIENCE
INTERNATIONAL
Contact HSI

Insights

Instructional Leadership: What Principals Do That Moves Teaching

Instructional leadership is real when it shows up as leader behavior: time in classrooms, specific feedback within a day, clear expectations, and reinforcement of improvement. Here is a weekly routine principals can keep, and how to share it with APs and coaches so it survives a busy building.

Ask a principal whether instruction is the priority and you'll get a yes, usually a sincere one. Ask the calendar and you'll often get a different answer. Buses, coverage, a parent meeting, a facilities issue, two referrals and a compliance deadline, and somehow it's 3:30 and nobody has watched anyone teach. No one plans the day that way. The day just tends to arrive that way.

That gap is where instructional leadership gets decided. Not in the vision statement, and not in anyone's intentions, but in what the leader of the building repeatedly does about teaching. A school improves when teaching improves, and teaching improves a lot faster when someone is paying attention to it on purpose.

Instructional Leadership Is a Set of Behaviors

So what is instructional leadership? Strip away the committee language and it comes down to four leader behaviors: time in classrooms, specific feedback delivered soon after, clear expectations about what good instruction looks like, and reinforcement of improvement when it shows up. A principal who does those four things regularly is an instructional leader, whatever the business card says. A principal who doesn't isn't one yet, however sincerely they believe in instruction.

I know that definition sounds plain, and that's deliberate. When instructional leadership in education gets defined as a mindset, a vision or a disposition, leaders have very little to work with, because you can't put a disposition on a calendar and you can't coach one either. Behaviors you can schedule, practice, measure and improve. It's the same argument I made about school culture: what people repeatedly do is the real thing, and everything else is the brochure.

To be clear, management matters too. Somebody has to run the buses, the budget and the master schedule, and a badly managed building buries good teaching under daily chaos. But management keeps the school running, and only intentional attention to teaching moves teaching. Those are different jobs, and only one of them happens by default.

Nobody has to schedule the interruptions. Somebody has to schedule the instruction.

The Calendar Tells the Truth

Time in classrooms comes first because every other instructional-leadership behavior depends on it. You can't give useful feedback on teaching you didn't see, and you can't reinforce improvement you never noticed. A principal who hasn't watched instruction in three weeks can still talk about instruction, but the conversation runs on secondhand information and good guesses.

The honest obstacle usually isn't commitment. It's the environment. The office produces a steady stream of urgent, solvable problems, and solving them pays off right away: the upset parent calms down, the coverage hole gets filled, the report gets submitted. Classroom time pays off slowly and quietly. Behavior tends to go where the payoff is, for principals as much as for anyone else, so left alone the role drifts toward the office one reasonable interruption at a time. Nobody decides that. It just happens.

A few questions are worth asking honestly. How much time did I actually spend around teaching last week? Which classrooms haven't seen me this month? When my calendar collapsed, what got cut first? And what does that pattern teach my staff about what this building values?

That last question is the heart of it. Teachers learn what leaders care about from where leaders spend their time, and short, frequent, predictable visits feel very different from the twice-a-year formal observation. When the principal shows up often, briefly, and without a clipboard-and-verdict routine, being observed stops being an event and starts being normal. That's a safer building to practice in, for everyone.

Feedback Within a Day, About One Thing

A classroom visit that produces no feedback is a sighting, not leadership. The teacher knows you were there and has no idea what you saw, which leaves plenty of room for the imagination, and imaginations in schools rarely fill that space with good news.

Useful feedback from a principal works the way useful feedback works everywhere: it's specific, it comes soon, and it's small. "You gave the direction once, waited, and the transition took half the time it did in September" gives a teacher something to keep doing. A generic compliment feels pleasant and carries almost no information. Aim to get the feedback to the teacher within a day, while both of you still remember the lesson, and keep it to one practice, not seven. Spend at least as much of it on what to keep as on what to change.

Delivered that way, feedback starts to function as support rather than surveillance. Teachers who regularly hear something specific and soon after a visit tend to stop dreading the door opening. Some even start asking for a visit, which is about the strongest signal a leader can get that the system is working.

Teach What Good Instruction Looks Like Here

Feedback assumes a shared picture of good teaching, and in a lot of buildings that picture lives in each observer's head. "Engagement" means one thing to the principal, another to the assistant principal, and a third to the coach, and teachers are left guessing which version walks in next. That isn't an expectations problem with teachers. It's a clarity problem with us.

Expectations about instruction work when they're few, observable and taught. Pick a small set of high-leverage practices, describe each one as something you could see or hear in any classroom, and teach them the way you'd teach any content: explain, show real examples, let people practice. "Clear directions" might look like giving the direction once, checking it with a couple of students, and starting the task within a minute. A one-page document beats a forty-indicator rubric that nobody can hold in mind during fourth period.

The test is simple. Could a teacher, an AP and a coach watch the same ten minutes of instruction and name the same two or three practices they saw? If yes, feedback from any of them will point in the same direction. If no, the building's walkthroughs are a weather system, and teachers will treat them accordingly.

Reinforce Improvement While It's Still Small

When teaching improves, it rarely improves all at once. It shows up small and fragile: a tighter transition, a better question, one more student answering than last month. If nobody notices, the new practice has to survive on its own against old habits that are easier and more comfortable, and effort that goes unnoticed tends to fade.

So the fourth behavior is noticing improvement, specifically and soon, and connecting it to what the teacher did. The usual honesty about recognition applies here. Praise or recognition isn't automatically reinforcement. It functions as reinforcement when it increases or maintains the behavior it follows, and we know by what happens to the behavior, not by what we intended. If the practice keeps showing up after you recognize it, keep doing what you're doing. If it doesn't, change your approach rather than repeating it louder.

For many teachers, the strongest payoff isn't anything the principal says. It's seeing their students respond: a calmer start, more hands up, less reteaching. Part of the leader's job is helping teachers connect the new practice to that change, because once the work itself starts paying off, it no longer depends on anyone's attention to survive.

A Weekly Routine That Fits a Real Building

Here's a weekly instructional-leadership routine I'd actually defend to a sitting principal. It's deliberately modest, because the routine that survives a hard week beats the ambitious one that collapses in October.

Three classroom blocks, scheduled first. Twenty to thirty minutes each, on the calendar before anything else lands, covering a few short visits apiece. If a genuine crisis takes one block, two still happen. The office line will re-form within the hour either way; it's one of the most reliable phenomena in education.

One instructional focus at a time. For several weeks, the building works on one practice from your shared picture of good instruction, and visits look mostly for that. One focus keeps feedback consistent, makes progress visible, and spares teachers the whiplash of a new priority every Monday.

Feedback within a day. Every visit produces one short, specific note: in person at the door, in a two-sentence email, on a sticky note. What to keep, and at most one next step.

One conversation about evidence. Once a week, sit down with your APs and coaches and talk about what you're all seeing across classrooms. Is the focus practice showing up? Where is it strong, and who needs more support? Patterns, not verdicts on individual teachers.

One public recognition, grounded in something seen. In the staff memo or the faculty meeting, name a practice you watched and what changed because of it. Specific recognition teaches the whole staff what the building is working toward. Generic shout-outs mostly teach people to skim the memo.

That adds up to roughly three hours in a week that runs well past fifty. Small, consistent and scheduled tends to beat big, impressive and occasional.

Too Big a Job for One Person

A principal who carries all of this alone has built something fragile. One hard month, one long absence, one brutal hiring season, and the routine disappears. This is where distributed leadership in schools stops being a slogan and becomes a design question: who else regularly watches teaching, gives feedback and reinforces improvement, and do we all mean the same thing when we do it?

Sharing the work can look like APs each owning a set of grade levels or departments for regular visits, while coaches carry the deepest coaching cycles. What makes it one system instead of three is the shared focus and the shared language, plus occasional calibration: watch the same ten minutes together, compare what you each saw, and reconcile the differences before teachers have to live with them. And keep the roles straight. As I wrote about the instructional coach's role, coaching has to stay separate from evaluation so teachers can practice without performing. Evaluation belongs to the administrators.

The principal's own job then shifts up a level: reinforce the instructional leadership of others. Ask your APs what they're seeing in classrooms, not only how the referral count looks, because what you ask about repeatedly is what they'll attend to. Notice when a coach's work shows up in a teacher's practice, and say so. The observation, feedback and reinforcement cycle underneath all of this is the one we teach as Deliberate Coaching®, and building it across a leadership team is the core of the leadership development work we do with schools and districts.

Final Word: Ask the Calendar Again

Instructional leadership doesn't announce itself. It shows up as blocks on a calendar that actually happened, feedback teachers can repeat back to you, a picture of good teaching that everyone describes the same way, and improvement that got noticed while it was still small.

So ask your calendar the question again in a month. Teachers will believe the calendar either way. Make it worth believing.

Want to Take This Further?

If your school or district is ready to turn instructional leadership from a title into a weekly routine, let's talk. A good place to start is the education keynote Deliberate Coaching: Using the Science of Behavior to Accelerate Performance and Growth, which shows leaders and coaches how to build the observation, feedback and reinforcement cycle this article describes.

I support state leaders, district leaders, department leaders, school leaders, team leaders, and classroom leaders through keynotes, professional development, coaching, and implementation support grounded in the science of human behavior.

When you're ready to talk about your building, reach out to HSI here.

Share

All Insights

Better Outcomes. Faster. Through Behavioral Science.

Ready to build a high-performing, values-driven organization?

Start with a conversation. HSI responds within two business days.